It is so difficult because Bodie is not Willie. Willie was the best GSD ever. He was sweet and gentle and protective and great at obedience.
It started from the moment I brought him home. Willie peed in the house when I first brought him home as a puppy and never had another accident. I was so lucky when I took puppy obedience class because it was so easy! I showed him to sit once and I never had to work that command again. The same thing happened with down, stay, and heel.
Bodie is not Willie.